CO129-116 - Sir MacDonnell - 1866 [11-12] — Page 117

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

115

Colored prisoners only 7-or less than 1 per cent on the total of 754.

25. Therefore the Colonial Surgeon's opinion of the improbability of the health of the Prisoners being affected by their removal to Victoria Gaol is so far corroborated by the test of practical experience. At the same time the further test of next summer has to be encountered, whilst it is also impossible to foresee accurately what may be the rate of increase or diminution in the number of prisoners hereafter. Your Lordships will remember that the measure as yet is essentially experimental, and that Stine Cutters' Island Gaol is kept ready for occupation at 24 hours notice.

We have undertaken that experiment, amongst other reasons, because the Colony cannot afford in its present unfortunate state of financial embarrassment to maintain two large establishments if one will suffice; or to dispense with the labor which is profitable here but wholly useless at Stine Cutters' Island - especially as I recognize no obligation to establish penal reformatories here for Chinese Criminals on the English model, and must regard such policy as involving unfair expenditure of the limited funds of a Colony so peculiarly situated as Hong Kong.

27. I now enclose a return shewing the probable saving in the next 12 months resulting from moving the prisoners to

Edit History

2026-05-19 12:16:44 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
115 Colored prisoners only 7-or less than 1 per cent on the total of 754. 25. Therefore the Colonial Surgeon's opinion of the improbability of the health of the Prisoners being affected by their removal to Victoria Gaol is so far corroborated by the test of practical experience. At the same time the further test of next summer has to be encountered, whilst it is also impossible to foresee accurately what may be the rate of increase or diminution in the number of prisoners hereafter. Your Lordships will remember that the measure as yet is essentially experimental, and that Stine Cutters' Island Gaol is kept ready for occupation at 24 hours notice. We have undertaken that experiment, amongst other reasons, because the Colony cannot afford in its present unfortunate state of financial embarrassment to maintain two large establishments if one will suffice; or to dispense with the labor which is profitable here but wholly useless at Stine Cutters' Island - especially as I recognize no obligation to establish penal reformatories here for Chinese Criminals on the English model, and must regard such policy as involving unfair expenditure of the limited funds of a Colony so peculiarly situated as Hong Kong. 27. I now enclose a return shewing the probable saving in the next 12 months resulting from moving the prisoners to
Baseline (Original)
115 Colored mers only 7-or less than 1 per prisoners cent on the total of 754. 25. Therefore the Colonial Surgeon's | opinion of the imfurbability of the health of the Prisoners being affected by their removal to Victorin Gool is so far- M corroborated by the test of practical experience: At the same time the further test of next summer has to be encountered, whilst -- it is also impossible to foresse accuratity which meny be the rate of ineres rease diminition in the number of prisoners hereafter. Your Sordships will remember that the measure as therefore yet is efsentially experimental, and that stime Cutters' Island Gaol is Kept ready for occupation at 24 hours notice. We That experiment has been undertaken, amongst other reasons, because the Colorry cannot afford in its present vide Governorts unfortunate state of financial embarra fement! See of State S. 156 dalik' 14 Nov-1 866 incloure 206 to maintain twe one will sun suffice; large Corind establishments if or to disperse with the labor which is profitable here but wholly useless at Stine Cutters' Island - especially RA Irecognize no obligation to establish penal reformatories here for Chinese Criminals on the English model, and must regard suck policy as involving unfair expenditure of the vent limited an funds of a Colony so peculiarly situated as 27. I Hang nang now enclose a return shewing, the probable saving in the next 12 months resulting from moving the prisoners to
2026-05-19 12:16:44 · Baseline
View content

115

Colored

mers only 7-or less than 1 per

prisoners

cent on the total of 754.

25.

Therefore the Colonial Surgeon's

| opinion of the imfurbability of the health

of

the Prisoners being affected by their removal to Victorin Gool is so

far-

M

corroborated by the test of practical experience: At the same time the further test of next summer has to be encountered, whilst --

it is also impossible to foresse accuratity

which

meny

be the rate of ineres

rease

diminition in the number of prisoners

hereafter. Your Sordships will

remember that the measure as

therefore

yet is

efsentially experimental, and that stime

Cutters' Island Gaol

is Kept ready for

occupation at 24 hours notice.

We

That experiment has been

undertaken, amongst other reasons,

because

the Colorry cannot afford in its present

vide Governorts unfortunate state of financial embarra fement!

See of State S. 156 dalik' 14 Nov-1 866

incloure 206

to maintain twe

one will sun

suffice;

large

Corind establishments

if

or to disperse with the labor which is profitable here but wholly

useless at Stine Cutters' Island - especially

RA

Irecognize no obligation to establish penal reformatories here for Chinese Criminals on the English model, and must regard suck policy as involving unfair expenditure of

the

vent

limited

an

funds of a Colony so

peculiarly situated as

27.

I

Hang nang

now enclose a return shewing,

the probable saving in the next 12 months resulting from moving the prisoners to

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.